a good time (not)

[Note: Jeff responded in the comments and I retract some of what I wrote here in my response.]

Here is Rush Limbaugh’s take on the Abu Ghraib photos and response:

This is no different than what happens at the Skull and Bones initiation and we’re going to ruin people’s lives over it and we’re going to hamper our military effort, and then we are going to really hammer them because they had a good time. You know, these people are being fired at every day. I’m talking about people having a good time, these people, you ever heard of emotional release? You heard of [the] need to blow some steam off?

When I read this I just started screaming incomprehensibly in my kitchen. I’m not sure how to argue with this point, or how to argue with Jeff’s apologia:

I think these prison guards slipped down a slope from frustration to anger and at some point took out that anger in an incomprehensible way. Read the description in that Times article of the inane stuff they made these Iraqis do and you begin to wonder what brought these people this far. If I was thrown in the same position would I have done any better? I don’t know.

This is a convenient theory that is very dramatic. I’m sure there are many plays that have been written in which a tense prison situation finally snaps and the guards enact a terrible scene of retribution and abuse, misdirected at a prisoner. I am not imputing Limbaugh’s view to Jeff, but they do share one idea: they see the torture of these prisoners as point events that are explicable given the circumstances.

Part of the point of military training as I understand it is to allow soldiers to make level-headed decisions in stressful situations. I have no idea how stressful it is out in the field where you are getting shot at, or in a prison where insurgents are trying to arrange prison breaks every night. Seymour Hersh cites the Taguba report:

There was a special women’s section. There were young boys in there. There were things done to young boys that were videotaped.

Abuses like that take premeditation. It is not a couple of people blowing off steam, nor is it slipping down the slope into a single incomprehensible act of violence. It shares the casual nature of the former and the degenerative aspect of the latter, but these acts were a way of life in this prison.

There is a separation that needs to be made between novelty and revulsion, and I think Jeff almost makes it. I was not surprised that abuses were happening in the prisons — after all, this is war, and war is not pretty and people do terrible things. I am nevertheless horrified at the casual nature of the violence, that this treatment of the prisoners had become so everyday. I am horrified that there have been three investigations and nothing has been done. I am horrified that this violence was sanctioned by higher authorities and that nobody is taking responsibility.

Things are better now than they were before. Perhaps prisons are better in Iraq than they are in the rest of the Middle East. But other Middle Eastern regimes do not pretend to be free societies that afford their citizens the rights that the US upholds. We are supposed to be building a model for a society, and we are tripping dangerously close to “come meet the new boss, same as the old boss.”

0 thoughts on “a good time (not)

  1. I don’t think I ever posed my commentary as a justification or defense of what happened. And in fact I’m intensely insulted that you would even lump my opinion on the same “side of the fence” as the ignorance spewed forth by Rush Limbaugh.

    Things are very probably worse than they appear because that slope of anger and retribution leads to an environment of abuse that is perpetuated night after night.

    On the other hand, things are also better than they appear. After a short (~10 days if I recall the Times article correctly) period of repeated abuse somebody caught on and stopped this. That isn’t a justification, but an observation.

    My real point is that this whole situation is such an unfathomable mess that I don’t think we can look at these events (the abuses) as isolated transgressions on the part of a few criminally deranged individuals. And when I said I didn’t know if I’d do any better…well I doubt I’d make some guy masturbate while looking at me, but I can imagine being incredibly tempted to beat the motherloving hell out of somebody–anybody if I had to do the night shift in a prison after sending my friend home in a body bag that afternoon.

  2. 1. Then I misunderstood your post, and I apologize. I thought that your point was that each incident was a personalized descent into madness, and “understandable” in the sense that there is an explanation (stress) which can lead to this sort of outcome. Your real point, stated above, I wholeheartedly agree with.

    2. I don’t think you’re on the same side of the fence as Rush. My understanding was that you were trying to humanize the actions of the guards (perhaps you still are) by providing an explanation for their behavior. Rush also humanizes the guards (in a sort of inhuman way) by saying that they were blowing off steam. My point was that this abuse was habitual, and humanizing a single event misses the point and comes close to humanizing this culture of abuse. This abuse was sanctioned by higher-ups, to boot, which takes away some of my sympathy.

    3. I should have excised the bit about you saying you’re not sure if you’d do any better. It was tangential to my point, and mischaracterizes you. I share your fears as well — we are all capable of terrible things, and in the pitch of the moment, who knows what we might do?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.